Follow along with the images and descriptions as a Morgan dollar begins to wear from freshly minted "Uncirculated" condition, to a very worn example in "Good" condition. Free shipping for many products! With the tidal wave of counterfeit Morgan dollars washing ashore over the past few years, two things continue to surprise me. The Carson City Mint was shut down in November 1885, and not reopened until October 1889. All of the date digits exhibit tiny lumps where the edge of the digit joins the field, and both 8s are a bit misshapen. These early dollars are becoming valuable. Unlike Silver Dollars produced in the years prior to the Morgan's release, the Morgan Silver Dollar boasted imagery that was intricate and beautiful in its design. The details are just a bit weak and fuzzy under higher magnification, and the rim of the coin is a little too flat when compared to a genuine example. Of the four mints that produced silver dollars in 1889, those struck at Carson City are very scarce today. Philadelphia Silver 1889 Year Morgan US Dollars (1878-1921) Shipping and returns View estimated shipping costs, . Also, mintmarks identifying the mint are valued separately. So, as a starting point, if youre noticing a wide variety of Morgans in this date range with the New Orleans Mint O mint mark, that should be your first clue that a forgery could be for sale. As there had been no local supply of silver dollars in the intervening four years, most of the mintage of 1889-CC Morgan dollars immediately began entering circulation. Sometimes, counterfeit dies are struck with insufficient force, creating weak details that easily identify a coin as a fake. Lower numbers indicate rarer coins. However, the rarity of the coin means that the luster has little effect on the price. The Survival Estimate represents an average of one or more experts' opinions as to how many examples survive of a particular coin in three categories: 1) all grades, 2) 60 or better, and 3) 65 or better. I'll admit I was wrong on my initial statement that it looks ok.. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. DavidM@HA.com. Please try again later. There is no probably. Berries above fletching off, @MsMorrisine said: The first surprise is how much better the Chinese counterfeiters are getting with their fakes, and the second is how often they make amateurish mistakes that make authentication easy. & H. Chapman 4/1904 - J.M. CU | Absence of wear, bright colorful toned luster and lack of contact marks sets this coin apart. However, Horace and Baby Doe had a loving marriage and two daughters, Elizabeth Bonduel "Lily" Tabor and Rosemary "Silver Dollar" Echo Tabor. Because the 1889-CC Morgan dollar is a rare key date, fakes abound. Condition makes a huge difference, and here is where you can find added value. Both are covered in detail further down the page, discovering an accurate 1889 Morgan silver dollar value. Clapp - John H. Clapp - Louis E. Eliasberg, Sr. - Bowers & Merena 4/1997:2280 - Jack Lee - Heritage 1/2009:4991, $531,875 - offered by Monaco Rare Coins in the May 21, 2012 issue of COIN WORLD, P.O.R. They urged the passage of another silver purchase act which would cause inflation and allow them to pay off their debts w/cheaper dollars. So, how can you spot a fake Morgan Silver Dollar? With interest in these beloved silver dollars reaching new heights, it's important to remember that counterfeiters often target this series. 1889-CC Morgan (real or fake?) BUY AND SELL COINS SAFELY AND WITH CONFIDENCE. Auction Record: $34,500 (MS67) Image: USA CoinBook The 1878-CC Morgan dollar was Carson City's contribution to the first year of Morgan dollar coinage. The Tabor mines made millions of dollars. A seam can be seen on the rim of the reverse. In the case of the 1889-CC shown here, the counterfeiter showed some ambition by joining the obverse of a Philadelphia Morgan bearing the 1889 date with the reverse of a Morgan bearing the 'CC' mintmark, likely from 1883 or 1884. When locked, you will be scrolled directly to this table for all coins. In this case, there is also an obverse marker that gives this Morgan Silver Dollar away as a counterfeit. The average 1889-CC Morgan dollar will have a full strike, but disappointing luster. Overall, the counterfeiter did a decent jobthis is one of the more deceptive counterfeits seen recently at NGC. Mintmarks are an important and deciding factor in value. Big lump of metal in front of lips to right of 6th star. I see the design is mushy and granular but I thought the point in the ear was part of the design and therefore not diagnostic of anything. A known online counterfeit coin store, A PCGS graded 1889-CC Morgan Dollar supposedly graded at AU50. To learn more about this counterfeit, click here. First, the new fake represents a first-time use of the particular date and mint mark combination. Fakeroo. The 1889-CC Morgan dollar pictured above appears to be an attractive coin in About Uncirculated condition worth well over $10,000. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network. (At least it should.lol). Particular coins being offered for sale may not have been included within particular indexes, and if included, may not have experienced the same market movements as the index as a whole. Unable to subscribe to our eNewsletter. Quick Links: The NGC spotted a very well-designed counterfeit Morgan Silver Dollar in a collection of the coins submitted for grading. Aside from that, the coin had a granular texture and lacked sharpness despite its well-circulated appearance. To learn more about this counterfeit, click here. Occasionally, a counterfeiter add toning or something else to distract a would-be buyer from potential flaws in a spurious coin. Poorly struck numbers in the date. The surfaces will feel different as well. Such a trick is suspected in the case of this counterfeit. Moderately worn examples sell for more than $1,000. Jun 9, 2019 43 Dislike Share Save Hoogie's Hobby Shop 423 subscribers Subscribe A brief look at the common tricks used by counterfeiters to fool collectors of the coveted 1889 Carson City. Auction Record: The NGC identified the 1893-O Morgan Silver Dollar, struck at the New Orleans Mint, as a well-made die that was struck with precision, save one flaw. Learn more>. Berries above fletching off. The most common type of fake is simply an added mintmark. The two bottom 1889-CCs have misshapen dates that clearly differ from those on any genuine 1889 dated Morgan dollars and uncharacteristically weak or missing portions of the eagle. Note the eye shape of a genuine Morgan dollar (left) versus the counterfeit (right). Silver dollars, the Morgan and Peace series, are in demand by dealers. Due to its value, this coin is an attractive target for counterfeiters. View the image to the right, its "uncirculated" condition stands out as far better than most surviving 1889 silver dollars. CHECK OUT COINS FOR SALE IN THESE POPULAR CATEGORIES, 2023 Amos Media Company. One of the most common are the misshapen letters RIB in the phrase E Pluribus Unum.. In the case of the Morgan Dollar pictured here, a counterfeiter opted to move metal around in the date on the obverse. NEW! NGC graders identify coins with added or altered mint marks each and every day. Your coin should exhibit a "like new" luster. Only 350,000 examples were struck at the Carson City Mint, and many ended up in melting pots later. I don't like the cut into the denticals that goes around the circumference. All rights reserved, May events surround launch of Kanakaole quarter, Mississippi dollar bag and roll sales start Aug. 28, Mint quarter dollar ornaments on sale starting Aug. 24, Buy & Sell Coins Online at the Coin World Marketplace. Someone added artificial toning to the coin, possibly in an attempt to divert attention away from the authenticity issues. The 1889-CC Morgan dollar is not only far and away the rarest Carson City silver dollar, but also a key date for the entire Morgan dollar series. The wrong reverse hub type was used on this particular coin. All Market Updates are provided as a third party analysis and do not necessarily reflect the explicit views of JM Bullion Inc. and should not be construed as financial advice. Images by Raymond Bruels III, courtesy of ANACS. Find many great new & used options and get the best deals for 1889-CC Morgan Silver Dollar $1, Circulated, Fine at the best online prices at eBay! Enter your email address and we will send you a link to reset your password. The 1893-O Morgan Silver Dollar counterfeit had a wide gap. Please try again later. About Uncirculated examples sell for . Overall, the counterfeiter did a decent jobthis is one of the more deceptive counterfeits seen recently at NGC. In this case, the obverse and edge of an 1889 Philadelphia dollar were combined with the reverse of one of the more common CC-mint Morgan Dollars, most likely an 1883 or 1884. Receive the highest price by separating the collectable from the bullion priced pieces. The reason why these guys polish their product is to remove defects like that chunk of metal. With Morgan Silver Dollars as popular as ever, counterfeiters are trying to cash in with advanced forgeries. There are always buyers interested in purchasing your coins. The 1889 Morgan Silver Dollar is a relatively common coin and minted in large quantities. This 1889-CC looks somewhat weird to me and I suspect it is counterfeit. Due to its value, this coin is an attractive target for counterfeiters. Also the folds in the cap show wear on the highest parts, the result of use and handling. John G. Mills - S.H. Why would a counterfeiter put two fake coins together? In contrast to the flood of previously rare 1881-CC and 1885-CC Morgan dollars released in the GSA hoard, only a single 1889-CC was found there. That is a stretch as there is one on both sides and it is probably just light on the crushed denticals. Uncirculated: A silver dollar in "uncirculated" condition has never circulated through commerce, thus no wear has occurred to its surfaces. I don't like the cut into the denticals that goes around the circumference. . Small details in her hair are now missing, most noticeable above her forehead and behind her neck. The 1889-CC Morgan dollar pictured above appears to be an attractive coin in About Uncirculated condition worth well over $10,000. Free Auction Appraisal Search Auction Archives. Note: A rare auction record and value of the scare 1889-CC dollar is detailed below. Coming Soon ..About Us - Contact Info - Advertise on CoinWeek - Sponsors - Terms and Conditions - Submit Articles - Questions & Help. Total Weight: 26.73 grams . The NGC and others have spotted fake Morgans with mint marks, such as the O of the New Orleans Mint, that are crooked or struck on a slant. Offerings of higher grade coins are apt to be one at a time instead of by the roll or bag. Even then, you should check the serial number with the photographs of the actual coin on the appropriate third-party coin grading service website. Morgan 1889-CC 1889 CC Morgan Dollars Early Silver Dollars Mintage: 350,000 Minted at: Carson City Designer - Engraver: George T Morgan Metal Composition: 90% Silver - 10% Copper Diameter: 38.1 mm Mass / Weight: 26.73 grams What This Coin Looks Like (Obverse, Reverse, Mint Mark Location, Special Features, etc. This fake has the tall CC Mint mark that was used from 1879 through 1893, proving that it is not genuine. To help collectors and dealers identify counterfeit coins, NGC has prepared lists of the most commonly counterfeited US, Chinese and world coins with diagnostic information and images from NGCs extensive database, as well as commentary from the NGC coin grading team. In reality, however, it is an alteration made from two coins carefully cut and then joined together to create a different date and mintmark combination. These alterations are seen so often that we devoted an entire article to them last year, which can be found here. There is high interest in the 2021 Morgan Dollars soon to be issued by the US Mint to commemorate the 100th anniversary of the silver series' swan song. PSA | Poorly struck letters on the reverse. These old coins are very liquid in the coin collecting market. The easiest diagnostic for this fake is something that a variety specialist will pick up quicker than the average collector. Listed as Rare in the value chart above, it's because any "uncirculated" 1889 Carson City silver dollar trades infrequently. The combination of small mintage, heavy circulation, and being melted down in 1918, means that Mint State 1889-CC Morgan dollars start in the five figures. 1890 congress passed the act to allow for more production of silver coinage than before David Lawrence Rare Coin Auctions sold the 1889 Carson City silver dollar pictured to the right. A seam can be seen on the rim of the reverse Click image to enlarge. Today, the Morgan Silver Dollar remains highly sought after. Introducing Coin World+ Get the brand-new mobile app! A fake 1879 Morgan Dollar (left) and a genuine example (right). Therefore this coin enjoys a wide range of popularity. Absence of wear, bright colorful toned luster and lack of contact marks sets this coin apart. No. All US and world coins graded by NGC are guaranteed to be genuine. While that article covered the most frequently seen mintmark alterationsremoved, added, and embossed mintmarksNGC graders recently identified an altered coin that did not fit into any of those categories. Copyright 2007-2023 Daniel A. HarrisAll Rights Reserved. The NGC cites the VAM reference as a good starting point to read up on known forgeries. The government melted down some 270 million Morgan Silver Dollars, a figure that was roughly half the entire mintage from 1878 to 1904. https://www.pcgs.com/setregistry/mysetregistry/album/160794, https://pcgs.com/setregistry/collectors-showcase/classic-issues-colonials-through-1964/zambezi-collection-trade-dollars/7345. All US and world coins graded by NGC are guaranteed to be genuine. All News, Articles, Commentary and Opinions are contributed by the author(s), with or without compensation, who are solely responsible for the content, and do not represent CoinWeek Management. Statistics are for Mint State coins only. 2023 CoinWeek DISCLAIMER: All content within CoinWeek.com is presented for informational purposes only, with no guarantee of accuracy. New Morgan Silver Dollar Fakes Spotted: Tips to Identify Common Forgeries. This fake 1878-CC Morgan dollar is a good example. Scarce in circulated grades and rare in the Mint State levels, this piece inspires strong bids when offered in auction settings. The fake. In extremely fine condition the value is around $4,250. All Rights Reserved. This counterfeit Morgan dollar error features rounded high points, dark areas and an eye that differes from a genuine specimen. It looks like you're new here. Extremely Fine: Slight but obvious removal of design and metal defines a worn silver dollar in "extremely fine" condition. Your 1889 Morgan silver dollar value rises quickly once determined it's a rare mint marked issue and especially when accurately graded. View the image to the right, its "uncirculated" condition stands out as far better than most surviving 1889 silver dollars. 1889 CC Morgan Dollar Repilca. Giving your coin character, some detail remains, large curls of hair behind the neck and a full "Liberty" in her coronet. Vice President - Heritage Auctions. Join NGC for free to add coins, track your collection and participate in the NGC Registry. All Morgan Silver Dollar coins were originally struck by the United States Mint with .900 silver content and .10 copper. Top 50 Most Commonly Counterfeited U.S. @Insider2 said: Morgan Dollars, for example, have been extensively cataloged by die variety (called VAMs after the comprehensive study by Leroy Van Allen and A. George Mallis). So, I'm curious to hear your opinions - Real or fake? Including more relating to your 1989 Morgan silver dollar value. Join NGC for free to add coins, track your collection and participate in the NGC Registry. 10 spot) is the 1893-S. Often, a counterfeiter will add an 'S' mintmark to a much more common example from Philadelphia (which has no mintmark). Definitely a fake several flags as enumerated above cast reproduction and polished to hide the casting featuresCheers, RickO, Fake, as stated above by several postersbut I could see how this coin might fool a new collector. Collectors Corner | That is a stretch as there is one on both sides and it is probably just light on the crushed denticals. HandsomeToad Urinist Howdy fellow coin peeps, :thumb: I found an interesting 1889-CC Morgan I believe to be a counterfeit and the bids are currently high, so I figured I post it here for the Morgan buffs to put their 2-cents in. Morgan Silver Dollars made between 1879 and 1899 with a hub that left a narrow gap between the eagles neck on the reverse and its right-facing wing. The weight, diameter and thickness of the fake are exactly the same as a genuine coin, and the sharpness of the finer details is very good. I have been offered a few counterfeits over the years, have 5 on my desk that we given to me of mostly dollars. Coin Values Moving with Precious Metals: Up-Dated 6/5/2023: Gold $1944 | Silver $23.45. If you already have a Morgan Silver Dollar and believe it may be fake, throw it on a scale. for most found today. Subscribe to the free NGC eNewsletter today! This seam was created when the forger removed the entire reverse of the 1889 Philadelphia dollar from within that line and replaced it with a reverse removed from a more common Carson City issue. I am also collecting at least one coin for each Roman emperor from Julius Caesar to ? After the Carson City Mint ceased coining operations for good in 1893, the coins stored in its vaults were transferred to the San Francisco Mint and the Treasury Department vaults in Washington, DC. Value charts, grading images and descriptions uncovers the common to rare coin values found in your box of old coins. Big lump of metal in front of lips to right of 6th star. Collectors wanting to protect themselves from counterfeit 1878-CC Morgan dollars may wish to pick up a copy of A Guide to the Varieties of the 1878 Carson City Morgan Dollar by John Roberts. Among the most commonly spotted are the following: The Carson City Mint and the Denver Mint are often given credit by counterfeiters for Morgan Silver Dollars they never struck in the first place. Such holders, with their distinctive black cores, were used for coins released from the GSA Hoard in the 1970s. Fold inside ear pointed Registry: CC lowballs (boblindstrom), bobinvegas1989@yahoo.com. I'd say fake. In reality, however, it is an alteration made from two coins carefully cut and then joined together to create a different date and mintmark combination. Find a rare date, mintmark or a better condition coin and Morgan silver dollar values start climbing. It has been abrasively polished which is also perhaps throwing me off. AU&AG clinches it with his VAM analysis. On the reverse the breast feathers and head of the eagle are subject to initial wear. Second, and of greater concern, it marks yet another fake Morgan Silver Dollar discovery in a two-year period. Join us today for FREE! Never been stung by one. The greater the detail remaining on your coin, the greater your 1889 Morgan silver dollar value. Worth over $21.40 1889 Morgan Silver Dollar The Morgan Silver Dollar, though out of production for more than 100 years at this point, is easily one of the most popular coins ever produced by the US Mint. Counterfeiters, hoping to avoid detection, will sell Morgans at low prices online and then disappear as a seller, often deleting the account used for the transaction. Save 47K views 11 years ago Coins and More - https://irixguy.com/coin Morgan Silver Dollars are an excellent way to own a piece of history, while concurrently Show more Shop the IrixGuy's. Step 1: Read Up on Known Forgeries The NGC and others maintain a list of known Morgan Silver Dollar forgeries that have come along. Poorly aligned mint marks. Greysheet Catalog Details. By creating an account, you are agreeing to the Terms of Service and the Privacy Policy. The following coins are included in the VAM reference: There are numerous signs of a fake Morgan Silver Dollar. PSE | When you take a closer look, some problems begin to surface. A true rarity and key date for the Morgan dollar series, the 1889-CC is a sought after by far more collectors than supply could possibly fulfill. The other Morgan on NGC's "Top 50" list is the 1889-CC. A seam can be seen on the rim of the reverse. KollectorKing Posts: 4,820 . Relative Rarity By Series ranks the rarity of this coin with all other coins of this Series. While that may seem like a lot, it is a lower mintage than 80% of Morgan Dollar issues. The same goes for uncirculated versions, which are usually bagmarked. In this case, the obverse and edge of an 1889 Philadelphia dollar were combined with the reverse of one of the more common CC-mint Morgan Dollars, most likely an 1883 or 1884. Compare this coin to the VAM5 as the VAM5 is the only dropped C reverse. It is, therefore, not considered particularly rare. Congratulations! I understand there are several of these known including example(s) in ANAs collection. Sign in or register to get started. Not only did the forger create a phony Morgan Dollar, but they also created a phony GSA Holder to house it. Want news like this delivered to your inbox once a month? Subscribe to the free NGC eNewsletter today! bob. Mint luster is now gone from the large exposed areas, the field in front of Liberty and her face. You have entered an incorrect email address! Retired dealer and avid collector of U.S. type coins, 19th century presidential campaign medalets and selected medals. Morgan Dollars, for example, have been extensively cataloged by die variety (called VAMs after the comprehensive study by Leroy Van Allen and A. George Mallis). $881,250
By judging the different stages of wear, a "Grade" is determined. While phony mintmarks are often glued to the coin (often creating a discolored area), this counterfeiter took things to another level by drilling through the edge of the coin to emboss a new mintmark from inside the coin! PCGS is not responsible for the accuracy or authenticity of Ebay listings. However there are some worth considerably more. A careful examination of this coin reveals a seam in the middle of the rim on the reverse. Free shipping for many products! Lets go back in time two years before we look at the latest counterfeit Morgan Silver Dollar. In the case of this coin, a counterfeiter created the appearance of an 1886-S issue (worth only a few hundred dollars) by adding a mintmark to an 1886 from Philadelphia, one of the easiest Morgans to find in Mint State. Gems are extremely rare, as are PLs and DMPLs. That polished look is fairly common on fakes. If you are ever unsure of a coins authenticity, you can either submit it to NGC for authentication or purchase a coin already certified by NGC. The value of a 1889 Morgan Silver Dollar can vary depending on the coin's condition, rarity, and demand. All include value charts, alongside grading images to find the accurate value of your old dollars. Therefore, the PCGS3000 should only be used as one guide to rare coin prices and historical price movements, and not as the sole source for determining the value or market history of a particular coin. The higher the number, the more rare the coin. The 1889-CC Morgan Dollar ( Buy on eBay) is recognized as one of the key date coins of the series. That one was too big. Their popularity is immense. Diameter: 38.10 millimeters Weight: 26.73 grams Mintage: 677,000 Mint: Carson City Metal: 90% Silver, 10% Copper Auction Record: $161,000 MS66 07-18-2013 Legend Rare Coin Auctions Rarity and Survival Estimates Condition Census Narrative Send Us Feedback Show Related Coins and Varieties (18) Hide Plus Grades to $25.79 Coins. Fold inside ear pointed Good: Your 1889 silver dollar in "good" condition is well worn with most of the metal forming the high reliefs of design removed. Open Auctions. ): The most common type of fake is simply an added mintmark. View Bio. Remember, it should weigh 412.5 grains, or 26.73 grams. But this fake has plenty of red flags, including the incorrect shape of Liberty's eye. The CC Mint mark on the reverse is also from the wrong year. In this case, the details in Liberty's hair and ear are unusually strong, outpacing what is expected from ones struck at the New Orleans mint. The troubling part of this latest discovery by the NGC is the fact that it represents a previously unreported contemporary counterfeit of the Morgan Silver Dollar, the 1894-O. I don't give an opinion that a coin is counterfeit or altered using just an image unless I am 100% positive. Silver Coins. 1 oz South African Gold Krugerrand - Random Dates, 2019 Patriot 1 oz Proof Like Silver Round - American Revolution, 1 oz Canadian Platinum Maple Leaf - Random Date. As I posted: It "probably" is. That's why I posted PROBABLY. Lower numbers indicate rarer coins. It is an excellent index with images and text links to all coin series, from Cents to Gold. Date by DateIn Depth Morgan Silver Dollar Value1878 to 1921, Morgan Silver Dollar Values | Popular and Valuable. Toning was added artificially to this fake 1878-CC Morgan dollar in an attempt to hide production defects. This seam was created when the forger removed the entire reverse of the 1889 Philadelphia dollar from within that line and replaced it with a reverse removed from a more common Carson City issue. You'll probably agree? MS68
Numismatic Rarity converts the Survival Estimate for a particular coin into a number from 1 to 10 (with decimal increments) based on the PCGS Rarity Scale. Is the thought each was hand made by seperating obverses and reverses and splicing each example together? . Unlike most other Carson City Morgan mintages, where the vast majority spent their existence in government vaults, most of the 1889-CC mintage went into circulation. Unless you are a professional expert in spotting counterfeits, it is strongly urged that you buy an authenticated, encapsulated sample. 3 Simple Ways to Spot a Fake Morgan Silver Dollar Petros7373 1.43K subscribers Subscribe 794 Share Save 244K views 11 years ago I bought some high quality Morgan Reproductions on eBay.
Hydroxycut Elite 100ct,
Stylevana First Order Coupon,
Puma Men's Cool Cat V Sandals,
5-minute Clinical Consult 2023,
Pottery Barn Espresso Cups,
Clarks Wave Walk Waterproof Shoes,
Burton Process Camber 2023,
Baldwin Prestige Knob,
Gianvito Rossi Portofino Heels,
Where To Buy Davidoff Cool Water,